A Cheese Lover’s Destination
For those who believe that cheese deserves its own food group, the Cheese Shoppe at Fair Oaks Farms is nothing short of paradise. Located within one of Indiana’s most well-known agricultural attractions, this specialty shop celebrates cheese in all its forms—fresh, aged, sliced, shredded, and, perhaps most deliciously, melted between two slices of bread. Visitors can explore a wide variety of cheese products made on-site and even order a grilled cheese sandwich prepared fresh to their liking.
Fair Oaks Farms, set among miles of northern Indiana farmland, is known for its innovative approach to agritourism. The Cheese Shoppe is part of a larger complex that includes a dairy adventure, farm tours, and hands-on exhibits. For travelers, it’s a chance to connect with the source of their food and taste the results of careful craftsmanship.
Farm-to-Table Cheese
At the heart of the Cheese Shoppe’s offerings is its farm-to-table philosophy. Milk from the farm’s own dairy cows is processed into cheese just steps away from where it’s sold. This direct connection ensures freshness, quality, and flavor that can be hard to find in mass-produced products. From creamy cheddar to tangy colby jack and smooth mozzarella, each cheese reflects the farm’s commitment to excellence.
Varieties for Every Palate
The Cheese Shoppe’s display cases are lined with wheels, blocks, and wedges of cheese in a wide range of flavors and styles. Mild cheeses appeal to younger visitors, while sharper, more complex varieties draw in connoisseurs. Seasonal and specialty cheeses—such as smoked gouda or pepper jack—offer something new for repeat visitors to discover.
Grilled Cheese to Order
One of the highlights for many guests is the shop’s grilled cheese counter. Here, sandwiches are made to order using the farm’s own cheese, baked bread, and fresh butter. Diners can choose from classic combinations or opt for a custom creation, selecting multiple cheeses and add-ins like tomatoes, bacon, or even apple slices for a sweet-savory twist.
A Comfort Food Classic
Watching a grilled cheese come together is part of the fun—the buttered bread sizzling on the griddle, the cheese slowly melting into a gooey layer, and the aroma filling the air. Served hot and golden brown, each sandwich offers the satisfying crunch of toasted bread followed by the indulgent richness of melted cheese.
Pairings and Sides
To complete the meal, the Cheese Shoppe offers sides such as soups, salads, and fresh fruit. A tomato soup paired with a grilled cheese remains a popular choice, especially during cooler months. Visitors can also sample cheese curds, a squeaky and addictive snack that’s made fresh daily.
Beverages and Treats
For drinks, options range from locally made sodas to farm-fresh milk. Sweet treats like ice cream and fudge are available nearby, giving guests plenty of reasons to linger and indulge in more than one course.
Educational Experiences
Part of the appeal of Fair Oaks Farms is its focus on education. Visitors can learn about the cheese-making process through exhibits and demonstrations, gaining a deeper appreciation for the skill and time required to turn fresh milk into a flavorful finished product. Glass viewing areas allow guests to see production in action, connecting the farm experience directly to what’s on their plate.
Sampling Before You Buy
The Cheese Shoppe encourages visitors to sample before purchasing, allowing them to compare flavors and textures firsthand. Knowledgeable staff are on hand to explain each cheese’s origin, aging process, and best uses in cooking. This interactive approach helps guests discover new favorites and make informed choices for their home kitchens.
Gift Boxes and Take-Home Options
For those wanting to share the experience, the shop offers pre-made gift boxes and customizable assortments. These packages often include a mix of cheeses, crackers, and other local products, making them ideal for holidays, special occasions, or as a souvenir of a day spent at the farm.
A Broader Fair Oaks Farms Experience
The Cheese Shoppe is just one part of what Fair Oaks Farms offers. The property is home to a variety of agricultural adventures, including tours of the dairy barns, pig farm, and seasonal events. Interactive exhibits teach visitors about sustainable farming practices, animal care, and modern technology in agriculture. It’s a destination where learning and fun blend seamlessly.
Hands-On for All Ages
Families often find that the Cheese Shoppe pairs perfectly with the rest of the Fair Oaks experience. Children enjoy tasting cheese curds, watching grilled cheese sandwiches being made, and seeing cows up close in the dairy barns. Adults appreciate the quality of the products and the chance to meet the farmers who make them possible.
Seasonal and Special Events
Throughout the year, Fair Oaks Farms hosts special events that highlight their cheese offerings. From harvest festivals to winter holiday markets, these gatherings often feature exclusive cheese flavors, cooking demonstrations, and live entertainment. Guests might even encounter limited-edition sandwiches or unique pairings designed just for the season.
Cheese in the Community
The Cheese Shoppe also supports the local community by sourcing ingredients from nearby producers whenever possible. This commitment to local partnerships strengthens the region’s economy and fosters a sense of pride in Indiana’s agricultural heritage.
Planning Your Visit
Located just off Interstate 65, Fair Oaks Farms is easily accessible for day trips from Chicago, Indianapolis, and other regional cities. The Cheese Shoppe is open year-round, with hours varying by season. Admission to the shop itself is free, though guests may choose to purchase tickets for the farm’s other attractions.
Tips for the Best Experience
Arriving early in the day ensures the widest selection of cheeses, especially for seasonal varieties that may sell out. Bringing a cooler can help keep purchases fresh during the trip home, especially in warm weather. For those with more time, pairing a visit to the Cheese Shoppe with a full farm tour offers a deeper appreciation of the journey from cow to cheese.
A Must-Visit for Cheese Enthusiasts
Whether you’re a casual fan or a devoted cheese aficionado, the Cheese Shoppe at Fair Oaks Farms delivers an experience worth savoring. With its combination of farm-fresh products, made-to-order grilled cheese sandwiches, and an educational backdrop, it’s more than a store—it’s a celebration of one of the world’s favorite foods.
For travelers passing through northern Indiana or families seeking a fun and flavorful outing, this spot offers a perfect blend of taste, tradition, and hospitality. And for anyone who believes a day with cheese is a day well spent, it may just be the highlight of your trip.
