The Juicy Lucy isn’t just a burger; it’s a story steeped in molten cheese and local pride. Two iconic bars, Matt’s Bar and the 5-8 Club, have been locked in a decades-long debate over who first created this cheesy masterpiece, sparking passionate discussions among Minnesotans and visitors alike.
No matter which side of the debate you fall on, one truth remains: biting into a Juicy Lucy is an unforgettable experience—a culinary hug from the inside. Let’s explore the top spots to indulge in this Minnesota classic and discover how each one adds its unique flair.
Matt’s Bar
Walking into Matt’s Bar feels like stepping into history. The décor is unpretentious, with walls lined with vintage memorabilia that remind you this place has been doing one thing—and doing it exceptionally—for generations.
The Juicy Lucy here is the stuff of legends: a perfectly grilled burger encasing gooey American cheese. The staff will give you one critical piece of advice: let it cool before biting in. Patience pays off as the first bite delivers an explosion of molten cheese and savory beef that epitomizes comfort food perfection.
5-8 Club
The 5-8 Club offers a Juicy Lucy experience with a twist. Unlike Matt’s, the 5-8 gives you options—cheddar, pepper jack, or even bleu cheese—allowing you to customize your burger to suit your cheese-loving preferences.
The cozy yet bustling atmosphere makes it a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Each bite is a delightful balance of flavors, with the melty cheese oozing out like liquid gold. If you love variety without sacrificing tradition, the 5-8 Club has you covered.
The Blue Door Pub: Innovation at Its Finest
For those looking to take their Juicy Lucy experience to the next level, The Blue Door Pub is a must-visit. Known for its inventive takes on the classic, the pub offers creations like the “Blucy,” which is stuffed with tangy blue cheese.
The menu is filled with experimental variations that push the boundaries of what a Juicy Lucy can be. Whether you’re a purist or an adventurous foodie, The Blue Door Pub delivers a burger experience that’s both surprising and satisfying.
The Nook: Juicy Lucy with a Twist
Nestled in a quiet St. Paul neighborhood, The Nook is a hidden treasure worth discovering. This cozy spot is famous for its classic Juicy Lucy paired with perfectly crisp crinkle-cut fries.
The Nook’s version stands out with a slight twist on traditional flavors, blending high-quality beef with cheese that melts in your mouth. It’s the kind of place where locals gather, and visitors feel like they’ve stumbled upon a best-kept secret.
WHonorable Mentions: More Juicy Lucy Stops
Beyond the heavyweights, several other establishments in the Twin Cities have made their mark on the Juicy Lucy scene. Each offers a unique spin on this Minnesota staple:
- Peppers & Fries: A burger joint with a creative streak, offering fun twists on the Juicy Lucy.
- Shamrocks: A sister restaurant to The Nook, serving up equally amazing burgers with a friendly pub vibe.
- Groveland Tap: Known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious take on the Juicy Lucy.
Whether you’re a Minnesota local or a visitor looking to taste one of the state’s most iconic foods, the Juicy Lucy offers something for everyone. From classic renditions to modern innovations, each bite is a reminder of why this molten cheese-filled burger has become a legend in its own right.
Ready to embark on your Juicy Lucy pilgrimage? Let the cheese-filled adventure begin!
