Along the scenic shores of Lake Superior in Two Harbors, there’s a cozy spot that has pie lovers from all over raving: the Rustic Inn Cafe. Though it may look like a humble roadside stop, inside you’ll find some of the most mouthwatering pies — and comfort food — in all of Minnesota.
A Homey Atmosphere That Feels Like Family
Step inside the Rustic Inn Cafe, and you’ll immediately feel the warmth. With its wood-paneled walls, cozy booths, and cheerful service, it feels less like a restaurant and more like visiting a favorite relative’s home. It’s the kind of place where conversation flows easily and homemade meals are the star of the show.
Pie That’s Worth the Trip
While the Rustic Inn Cafe serves excellent breakfasts, sandwiches, and hearty dinners, the real claim to fame here is the pie. Their bakers craft over 25 varieties, all made fresh daily with flaky, buttery crusts and generous fillings. From classics like blueberry and apple to more decadent options like caramel apple pecan and five-layer chocolate, every pie is a slice of heaven.
Locals and visitors alike agree: the Rustic Inn’s pie is so good, you’ll be thinking about it long after the last bite.
Beyond the Pie: Comfort Food Favorites
If you can tear yourself away from dessert for a moment, the rest of the menu is just as satisfying. Favorites include wild rice soup, hearty burgers, and fresh-caught fish dishes that highlight the flavors of northern Minnesota. Everything here is made with care and hearty Midwestern generosity.
A Perfect Stop Along Highway 61
The Rustic Inn Cafe is ideally located along Highway 61, making it the perfect stop on a North Shore road trip. After visiting Gooseberry Falls or Split Rock Lighthouse, a meal — and definitely a pie — at Rustic Inn is the perfect way to round out your day of adventure.
They even offer frozen pies to-go, so you can bring a little taste of Two Harbors home with you.
A Sweet Tradition You Won’t Want to Miss
In a state full of fantastic bakeries and cafes, the Rustic Inn Cafe stands out for its incredible pies, welcoming atmosphere, and genuine small-town charm. Whether you’re passing through or planning a special trip just for dessert, this tiny bakery is bound to leave a big impression.
